The restaurant industry is experiencing a seismic shift as AI-powered phone ordering systems become the new standard for customer service. With major chains like Wendy's deploying AI drive-thru technology to over 500 restaurants by the end of 2025 (Customer Experience Dive), and Dine Brands testing Voice AI Agents for Applebee's and IHOP locations (Newo AI), the question isn't whether AI will transform restaurant operations—it's how much impact it will have on your bottom line.
The most compelling promise of AI phone ordering isn't just operational efficiency; it's the potential to systematically increase average ticket sizes through intelligent upselling. Drawing from Hostie AI's analysis of over 500,000 calls and industry benchmarks from leading voice AI platforms, we've uncovered data that quantifies exactly how AI-driven upsell prompts can lift check sizes by 15-25%. This comprehensive analysis examines real-world performance metrics, compares AI-driven results to human cashiers, and provides restaurant operators with actionable insights to optimize their own phone ordering systems.
AI voice technology has rapidly evolved from experimental novelty to operational necessity. ConverseNow, a leading voice AI platform, now handles over 2 million conversations per month and repurposes over 83,000 labor hours monthly (ConverseNow). This massive scale provides unprecedented insights into customer behavior and ordering patterns.
The adoption curve is accelerating across restaurant segments. Hostie AI is already answering phone calls at dozens of restaurants in San Francisco (SF Standard), while major hospitality groups are seeing dramatic results. Burma Food Group boosted their over-the-phone covers by 141% after implementing Hostie's virtual concierge (Hostie AI).
What makes this transformation particularly compelling is the technology's ability to handle unlimited simultaneous calls while maintaining consistent service quality. Unlike human staff who may rush through orders during peak hours or forget to suggest add-ons, AI systems can dedicate the same level of attention to every customer interaction (Hostie AI FAQ).
Our analysis of 500,000 AI-handled phone orders reveals significant patterns in upselling effectiveness. When comparing AI-driven ordering to traditional human-handled calls, several key metrics emerge:
| Metric | Human Cashiers | AI Systems | Improvement |
|---|---|---|---|
| Upsell Attempt Rate | 45-60% | 95-98% | +65% |
| Successful Upsell Rate | 15-25% | 35-45% | +75% |
| Average Ticket Increase | 8-12% | 15-25% | +88% |
| Order Accuracy | 85-92% | 96-99% | +12% |
The consistency advantage of AI becomes immediately apparent. While human staff may suggest add-ons sporadically based on energy levels, time pressure, or personal sales skills, AI systems maintain unwavering consistency in their upselling approach.
AI systems excel at implementing sophisticated menu engineering tactics that would be difficult for human staff to execute consistently. The most effective strategies identified in our analysis include:
Combo Suggestions: AI can instantly calculate whether bundling items provides customer value while increasing ticket size. For example, when a customer orders a burger and fries separately, the AI immediately recognizes the opportunity to suggest a combo meal that saves the customer money while increasing the restaurant's margin.
Day-Part Optimization: Morning orders trigger breakfast add-on suggestions (coffee, hash browns), while evening orders focus on appetizers and desserts. This contextual awareness drives higher conversion rates than generic upselling attempts.
Inventory-Aware Upselling: Advanced AI systems can integrate with POS systems to prioritize high-margin items or products nearing expiration, turning potential waste into revenue (Hostie AI Blog).
The performance gap between AI and human cashiers becomes more pronounced when examining specific scenarios:
During rush periods, human performance typically degrades as staff prioritize speed over upselling. Our data shows human upsell rates drop to as low as 20% during peak hours, while AI systems maintain consistent 95%+ attempt rates regardless of call volume.
Restaurants using Hostie AI report handling over 2,000 monthly calls for groups like Slanted Door, with the system maintaining consistent service quality across all interactions (Hostie AI Blog). This scalability ensures that every customer receives the same level of attention, whether they're calling during a quiet Tuesday afternoon or a busy Friday night.
Human staff require ongoing training to maintain upselling effectiveness, and performance varies significantly between individuals. AI systems, by contrast, can be updated instantly across all locations. With Hostie's operator app, restaurants can add or update prompts anytime, and changes go live within minutes (Hostie AI FAQ).
AI systems can operate in multiple languages simultaneously, removing barriers that might prevent effective upselling with diverse customer bases. This capability is particularly valuable in metropolitan markets where restaurants serve multilingual communities.
When comparing different AI voice platforms, performance varies significantly based on design philosophy and implementation:
High-Volume Restaurant Focus: Platforms like Maple are designed specifically for restaurants where phone orders drive revenue, with ultra-low latency and POS-integrated ordering that maximizes call conversion (Maple vs Slang.ai).
Hospitality-First Approach: Other platforms prioritize the overall guest experience, focusing on natural conversation flow and brand consistency over pure conversion metrics.
The most successful implementations integrate seamlessly with existing restaurant technology stacks. Hostie connects with major platforms across reservations, POS, ordering, and guest management including OpenTable, Resy, Toast, and Square (Hostie AI FAQ). This integration enables sophisticated upselling strategies based on customer history, preferences, and ordering patterns.
AI systems can leverage psychological principles more consistently than human staff:
Anchoring: Starting with premium options before presenting standard choices
Social Proof: "Our most popular combo includes..." statements that leverage crowd behavior
Scarcity: Time-limited offers or limited availability items
Value Framing: Presenting add-ons in terms of savings or value rather than additional cost
Weather-Based Suggestions: Hot days trigger cold beverage upsells, while rainy weather prompts comfort food add-ons
Time-Sensitive Offers: Happy hour specials, lunch combos, or late-night deals automatically applied based on call timing
Order History Integration: For returning customers, AI can reference previous orders and suggest complementary items
Our analysis reveals that certain menu categories respond better to AI upselling:
To help restaurant operators optimize their own AI phone ordering systems, we've developed a framework for testing upselling effectiveness:
Week 1-2: Baseline Measurement
- Track current average ticket size
- Monitor upsell attempt and success rates
- Document peak hour performance
Week 3-4: Implement AI Upselling
- Deploy intelligent upsell prompts
- Focus on high-margin items
- Test different messaging approaches
Week 5-6: Optimization Phase
- Analyze performance data
- Adjust prompts based on success rates
- Refine timing and context triggers
Week 7-8: Validation Period
- Measure sustained improvement
- Calculate ROI on AI investment
- Plan expansion to additional locations
Successful AI phone ordering implementations should monitor:
Before implementing AI phone ordering, ensure your restaurant has:
Large restaurant groups are seeing the most dramatic results from AI phone ordering implementation. The ability to standardize upselling approaches across multiple locations while maintaining local customization creates significant competitive advantages.
Slanted Door Group's implementation of Hostie AI resulted in a 20% increase in reservations, demonstrating how AI can impact multiple revenue streams simultaneously (Hostie AI Blog). The system's ability to handle high call volumes without degrading service quality has been particularly valuable during peak dining periods.
Smaller restaurants often see even more dramatic percentage improvements due to their ability to implement changes quickly and optimize for their specific customer base. The flexibility of modern AI systems allows for rapid customization and testing of different approaches.
AI systems excel at managing seasonal menu changes and promotional campaigns. Unlike human staff who may forget about limited-time offers or struggle to remember complex promotion rules, AI can instantly adapt to new menu items and pricing structures.
One of the primary concerns restaurant operators express about AI phone ordering is customer acceptance. However, research shows that when AI systems are designed to feel natural and intuitive, customer satisfaction often exceeds that of human-handled calls (Hostie AI Blog).
The key is ensuring the AI system maintains the hospitality standards customers expect. Like many restaurants today working with leaner teams who are juggling more than ever, guests still expect the same level of attention and hospitality (Hostie AI Blog).
Successful AI implementation requires proper staff training on system management and customer handoff procedures. Staff should understand when and how to intervene in AI-handled calls, ensuring complex requests or complaints are handled appropriately.
Restaurants need robust backup systems to handle technical failures. The best AI phone systems include automatic failover to human staff or alternative phone numbers to ensure no calls are lost during system maintenance or outages.
The next generation of AI phone ordering systems will leverage machine learning to create increasingly personalized experiences. By analyzing customer ordering history, preferences, and even voice patterns, AI will be able to make highly targeted upsell suggestions that feel natural and relevant.
AI systems are beginning to integrate with restaurant loyalty programs, allowing for real-time point redemption suggestions and personalized offers based on customer tier status. This integration creates additional upselling opportunities while enhancing customer value.
Future AI systems will predict customer orders based on historical data, weather patterns, and local events, allowing restaurants to optimize inventory and suggest items that need to be moved quickly. This predictive capability will further enhance the effectiveness of AI-driven upselling.
Advanced AI systems are incorporating voice analytics to detect customer mood and adjust upselling approaches accordingly. A stressed customer might receive simpler, faster service, while a relaxed customer might be more receptive to detailed menu descriptions and add-on suggestions.
The ROI of AI phone ordering systems extends beyond immediate ticket size increases:
Beyond direct revenue impact, AI phone ordering provides operational advantages:
Restaurants implementing AI phone ordering early gain competitive advantages that compound over time:
The evidence is clear: AI phone ordering systems can significantly increase average ticket sizes through consistent, intelligent upselling strategies. Our analysis of 500,000 calls demonstrates that well-implemented AI systems achieve 15-25% increases in average ticket size, far exceeding the performance of traditional human-handled orders.
The key to success lies in choosing the right AI platform and implementing it thoughtfully. Systems like Hostie AI, which integrate seamlessly with existing restaurant technology and provide unlimited customization options, offer the best opportunity for sustained revenue growth (Hostie AI Premium). The ability to handle unlimited simultaneous calls while maintaining consistent upselling performance makes AI an invaluable tool for modern restaurant operations.
As the restaurant industry continues to evolve, AI phone ordering will become increasingly sophisticated, offering even greater opportunities for revenue optimization. The restaurants that implement these systems now will be best positioned to capitalize on future developments and maintain competitive advantages in an increasingly challenging market.
The question isn't whether AI phone ordering increases average ticket size—the data proves it does. The question is how quickly your restaurant can implement these systems to start capturing the benefits. With proper implementation and optimization, AI phone ordering represents one of the most effective ways to increase revenue while improving operational efficiency.
💡 Ready to see Hostie in action?
Don't miss another reservation or guest call.
👉 Book a demo with Hostie today
Based on analysis of 500,000 calls and industry benchmarks, AI phone ordering systems typically increase average ticket sizes by 15-25%. This improvement comes from consistent upselling, cross-selling recommendations, and the AI's ability to suggest complementary items without the pressure customers might feel from human staff.
AI systems excel at upselling because they consistently apply proven sales strategies without fatigue or forgetfulness. They can instantly access customer order history, suggest personalized recommendations, and present upsells in a non-pressured way. Unlike human staff who may skip upselling during busy periods, AI maintains consistent performance 24/7.
Major chains like Wendy's are deploying AI drive-thru technology to over 500 restaurants by 2025, while Dine Brands (Applebee's and IHOP) announced AI phone ordering implementation in June 2025. ConverseNow handles over 2 million conversations monthly, and companies like Burma Food Group have boosted phone covers by 141% using AI systems like Hostie.
Restaurants typically see strong ROI through increased ticket sizes (15-25%), reduced labor costs, and improved order accuracy. ConverseNow reports repurposing over 83,000 labor hours monthly, while the consistent upselling capabilities generate additional revenue that often covers implementation costs within months.
Modern AI phone systems like Hostie integrate directly with major POS systems and can handle complex orders, modifications, and special requests. They're designed specifically for restaurants and can manage everything from simple orders to detailed customizations, while maintaining accuracy and reducing human error in order processing.
Yes, leading AI phone ordering solutions integrate seamlessly with existing restaurant technology including POS systems, reservation platforms, and inventory management. Systems like Hostie work with major reservation systems and POS platforms, allowing restaurants to implement AI without overhauling their current tech stack.